Skip to main content

Why can't a isothermal process be adiabatic?

"Why can't a isothemal process be adiabatic?"

This was the question my housemate, that studies geology and geography, asked me while studying for his thermodynamics test. As a chemical engineering student I was suppose to be able to answer him immediately, but it took me some pondering to give him a good answer.

Lets consider the isothermal expansion of gas, and lets use the convention used by most thermodynamic textbooks that work (W) done by the system on the environment is said to be negative.
Consider the diagram and the formula used for work done by isothermal expansion of an ideal gas and the heat formula.
Isothermal expansion


Work done by isothermal expansion of an ideal gas
Heat formula for expansion of an ideal gas in a closed system
And because, for reversible isothemal expansion the following is true:
For reversible isothermal expansion 
thus we can see that Q = -W, and W is not equal to 0 because the volume has changed, that means that Q is also not equal to 0.

Keeping the above mentioned in mind, we can now look at the conditions for reversible adiabatic expansion, that is Q=0, and because we know that Q is not equal to 0 in a isothermal expansion system,  this is the reason that a isothermal process cannot be adiabatic.

Now as I will always try to do is give an real life example that I think is fitting for the discussed theory. I don't know if you have ever noticed a can of deodorant becomes colder when you use it, or if you are a mountain biker like me you might have used one of those CO2 gas-bomb  tire inflation devices those things can literally freeze to your hand if your not carefull, well that is because of the expansion of gas, take a look at the regulator of a CO2 tank that froze up because of the gas expanding from the high pressure cylinder to atmospheric pressure.

CO2 regulator freezing up
So for this process to be isothermal on a closed piston cylinder assembly, heat needs to be transferred from the environment to the system to keep the temperature constant, thus Q is not equal to 0, making it isothermal but not adiabatic.
Labels:

Comments

  1. Unknown16 November 2015 at 20:32

    If it is a closed system and a free expansion it's possible.I would also be possible with a control volume, for instance take a look at the isenthalpic expansion of a gas.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How to plot an XY diagram for McCabe Thiele method in Aspen Plus

Its been a really long time since I made any posts, sorry for that but work sometimes gets in the way of the things I like doing, like updating my blog. This post might seem a bit stupid but I tried to find out how to do this on the web and it was quite impossible to find a easy step by step guide for making a XY plot in Aspen Plus for use in the McCabe Thiele method for designing a distillation coulomb, so I had to figure it out myself after a lot of fellow class mates had the same problem as me. So without any further a dew here is my 13 steps to making a XY plot in Aspen Plus for a binary mixture. For this example I used the old classic ethanol and water problem. Step1:  Open Aspen Plus and this is the first screen to pop up. Choose "Blank Simulation" an press "Ok" Step 1: Begin new Aspen simulation Step2:  You are now in the simulation environment and to start the simulation you need to enter the "Data Browser" (Usual simulations you would...
5 comments
Read more

Designing a C5/C6 Isomerization unit

As a final year student we need to design a catalytic isomerization unit that effectively rises the octane number by isomerization of n-butane, n-pentane and n-hexane into their respective isomers. I was responsible for the design of the reactor, this was probably the most difficult thing I have done in engineering since I started the course. It took a lot of hard work, but in return I am most certainly a much better engineer.... (P.S. The most difficult part of the project was finding the correct reaction kinetics, and just a note to the reader, I do not fully trust the kinetics that was used in this design.) 3.1        Reactions and Kinetics n-Butane In a process such as the Penex process where carbon strings from C4-C6 are present a large amount of possible reactions can take place in the form of isomerisation and cracking. We will begin by considering the short straight chains and their reaction and kinetics first then move to the cyclic molecule...
1 comment
Read more